New Vs Old - GTA III iPHONE VS GTA

[Darran@Retro Gamer]

For the letters page

[Scapegoat]

Err, one vote for GTA III on my android tablet due to the native Xbox controller support.

[ipmarks]

When you say GTA do you mean the top down GTA from the 90's or GTA III on the PC/PS2 etc.?

I think I prefer the PC GTA III to the iPhone one, as the iPhone one is a pain to control to be honest. I do however prefer the iPhone GTA III to the original top down PC GTA which I never really got along with...
Hopefully some of that made sense.

[thevulture]

GTA 3 on PS2/Xbox-I can quite happily throw a controller to the floor in a fit of temper due to some of the games flaws (rubbish A.I on other road traffic, time limits etc) and pick it up, no harm done.

ipad though...very different matter.

[MattyC64c]

GTA III on the Xbox or PS2 is still better than the iPhone. I suspect that it would be easier to play on an iPad, what with the bigger screen real estate, but nothing beats a proper controller does it. From a technical point of view I think it's pretty amazing that they can fit these console games into a mobile phone and have them look the same as the originals.

[AmigaJay]

Any version over a touchscreen GTA!

[Timothy Lumsden]

GTA Chinatown wars is more fun than either imho

[Kai]

The PS2 version is unsurpassable. The iPhone has some very interesting games but the touch controls suck (not on a technical level though), imho. Nothing beats real buttons.