Captain conundrum

A place to discuss anything retro that isn't games related

Moderators: mknott, NickThorpe, lcarlson, Darran@Retro Gamer, MMohammed

Kirk or Picard?

Poll ended at Thu Sep 13, 2007 3:29 pm

Kirk
6
40%
Picard
9
60%
 
Total votes: 15

User avatar
paranoid marvin
Posts: 14272
Joined: Mon Jan 23, 2006 6:28 pm
Location: 21st Century Earth

Captain conundrum

Post by paranoid marvin » Mon Sep 03, 2007 3:28 pm

Kirk or Picard - which would YOU choose at the helm of the Enterprise?
Mr Flibble says...
"Game over , boys!"

User avatar
paranoid marvin
Posts: 14272
Joined: Mon Jan 23, 2006 6:28 pm
Location: 21st Century Earth

Post by paranoid marvin » Mon Sep 03, 2007 3:35 pm

A difficult choice - Picard is the more diplomatic of the two , but Kirk is the craftier . Kirk can let his emotions get the better of him , so for a cold calculated decision , I guess it has to be Picard
Mr Flibble says...
"Game over , boys!"

User avatar
felgekarp
Posts: 9351
Joined: Fri May 05, 2006 11:47 am
Location: Earth 3

Post by felgekarp » Mon Sep 03, 2007 3:54 pm

Toupee + flying kick = kirk all the way.
Splink!

User avatar
Xesh
Posts: 1245
Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2007 8:50 pm
Location: Canterbury, Kent

Post by Xesh » Mon Sep 03, 2007 3:57 pm

Don't forget the neck chop. :)

User avatar
McBoosh
Posts: 283
Joined: Sun Aug 05, 2007 12:49 pm
Location: Somerset

Post by McBoosh » Mon Sep 03, 2007 4:43 pm

Has. To. Be. Kirk.

FIRE!

User avatar
DrBlue
Posts: 307
Joined: Mon Jan 15, 2007 2:32 pm
Location: Lancashire

Post by DrBlue » Mon Sep 03, 2007 5:11 pm

We've all seen it before, but by god is it funny: 100 Reasons Why Kirk is Better Than Picard

http://www.vigyan.com/~blbates/star_tre ... icard.html

My favourite:

56:If there was ever a Klingon on Kirk's bridge, Kirk would likely be dead.


In fairness I'm also a big fan of Picard too.

I think there should also be options for Sisko and Janeway, who are also great commanders in their own right.

Captain Archer is a different story altogether...don't get me started...
Image

User avatar
paranoid marvin
Posts: 14272
Joined: Mon Jan 23, 2006 6:28 pm
Location: 21st Century Earth

Post by paranoid marvin » Mon Sep 03, 2007 5:18 pm

I always tjought it would be interesting to see how Kirk would have dealt with the Borg

Oh , and as for other captains - surely only these 2 count?
Mr Flibble says...
"Game over , boys!"

User avatar
DrBlue
Posts: 307
Joined: Mon Jan 15, 2007 2:32 pm
Location: Lancashire

Post by DrBlue » Mon Sep 03, 2007 5:19 pm

Yeah probably, seeing as they are the best known among none trekkers.
Image

User avatar
paranoid marvin
Posts: 14272
Joined: Mon Jan 23, 2006 6:28 pm
Location: 21st Century Earth

Post by paranoid marvin » Mon Sep 03, 2007 5:23 pm

DrBlue wrote:Yeah probably, seeing as they are the best known among none trekkers.
and also because none of the others comes close to their screen presence

*although one could argue that , albeit for a short period , Khan was captain , and he would rank alongside the other two
Mr Flibble says...
"Game over , boys!"

User avatar
paranoid marvin
Posts: 14272
Joined: Mon Jan 23, 2006 6:28 pm
Location: 21st Century Earth

Post by paranoid marvin » Mon Sep 03, 2007 5:34 pm

Another reason I prefer Picard to Kirk is that the latter is far more of a fantasy character. Whereas in the episode where Picard is tortured , and close to breakdown , and is only rescued at the last thanks to outside intervention , Kirk would have somehow turned the tables on his torturer and fought his way back to the Enterprise - far more entertaining perhaps , but far less realistic. Another reason why I prefer the more serious action of TNG to the more 'fun' original series.

Having said that , Kirk was perhaps a character of the '60s . By the time the films started to be released some 10 or more years later , the character of Kirk was very dissimilar to that portrayed in the tv series.
With the possible exception of IV , much of the humour and womanising prevalent in the '60 Kirk had been replaced with a more serious character
Mr Flibble says...
"Game over , boys!"

User avatar
Wildnites
Posts: 607
Joined: Thu Feb 02, 2006 2:38 pm

Post by Wildnites » Tue Sep 04, 2007 5:19 am

paranoid marvin wrote:Another reason I prefer Picard to Kirk is that the latter is far more of a fantasy character. Whereas in the episode where Picard is tortured , and close to breakdown , and is only rescued at the last thanks to outside intervention
THERE ARE FOUR LIGHTS.....


:lol: :lol:
Please Sir I cannot tell a lie......

User avatar
merman
Posts: 6548
Joined: Wed Nov 30, 2005 5:14 pm
Location: Skegness, UK
Contact:

Post by merman » Tue Sep 04, 2007 5:47 am

They are both great captains with their own strengths and weaknesses...

It would have been interesting to see the cancelled Star Trek Phase II, with Kirk confined to the bridge more and the second in command (the character that became Will Decker in Star Trek The Motion Picture) going on away missions (which is how Will Riker's role became in TNG)
merman1974 on Steam, Xbox Live, Twitter and YouTube

User avatar
RetroENZO
Posts: 155
Joined: Thu Jul 26, 2007 2:08 pm
Location: South Wales
Contact:

Post by RetroENZO » Tue Sep 04, 2007 11:01 am

This old debate again?
Geoff
Facebook and Twitter
Image

User avatar
DrBlue
Posts: 307
Joined: Mon Jan 15, 2007 2:32 pm
Location: Lancashire

Post by DrBlue » Wed Sep 05, 2007 4:13 pm

Another reason why I prefer the more serious action of TNG to the more 'fun' original series.
A very valid view. Although they increasingly sucked alot of that fun out of the franchise by bogging it down with it's own mythology (you know who you are Enterprise). Even alot of Star Trek fanboys (like me) who knew all of the back stories didn't enjoy Enterprise because of it's unrelenting tedium (although Jeffrey Coombs' character Shran enlivened proceedings occasionally and Dr Phlox was a great character).

What Star Trek needs right now is a series that can recapture the fun and adventure of the original series whilst incorporating the 'human element' of the stories from TNG (the Picard - Cardassian interrogation story you refer to is a prime example).
Image

Madge
Posts: 447
Joined: Thu Dec 07, 2006 5:01 pm

Post by Madge » Wed Sep 05, 2007 4:24 pm

I read that there's a new Star Trek film in the works with Greg Hemphill as a possible Scotty. Hoax?
Why retro? Because you never forget your first love.

Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest